Conflict of Interest

Conflict of Interest Policy

Acman: Accounting and Management Journal is committed to preserving objectivity, transparency, and scientific integrity across all stages of the peer-review and publication processes. A conflict of interest (also referred to as a competing interest) arises when financial, personal, commercial, academic, or institutional relationships could improperly influence—or be perceived to influence—the conduct, evaluation, or reporting of scholarly research.

To safeguard public and academic trust, all key participants in the publication workflow—authors, peer reviewers, and editors—must explicitly declare any potential or actual conflicts of interest.

1. Guidelines for Authors

All submitting authors must disclose any financial, professional, or personal competing interests that might be perceived as biasing the research design, data interpretation, or manuscript conclusions.

  • Financial Conflicts: Authors must disclose all sources of funding, research grants, honoraria, employment, consultancies, stock holdings, or patent rights relevant to the submitted work.

  • Non-Financial Conflicts: Authors must declare non-financial relationships, including personal or professional connections, academic rivalries, institutional affiliations, or ideological commitments that could influence their objectivity.

  • Funding Statement: Authors must explicitly declare all external funding sources in the manuscript, detailing the specific role of the funding entity in study design, data collection, analysis, drafting, or publication decisions.

  • Declaration Statement: Authors must include a formal Conflict of Interest Statement prior to the Reference list.

2. Guidelines for Peer Reviewers

Peer reviewers play a critical role in upholding scholarly rigor and must maintain strict impartiality.

  • Mandatory Recusal: Reviewers must decline invitations to evaluate a manuscript if they have a known financial, collaborative, personal, or institutional conflict of interest with any of the authors, funding agencies, or affiliated organizations.

  • Examples of Conflict: Competing interests include recent co-authorship, ongoing research collaborations, supervisor-student relationships, or direct commercial competition with the authors.

  • Confidentiality & Non-Exploitation: Reviewers must not use unpublished ideas, data, or concepts disclosed in a manuscript under review for their own research, personal advantage, or financial gain.

3. Guidelines for Editors & Editorial Board

Editors hold the ultimate responsibility for publishing decisions and must uphold complete neutrality.

  • Recusal Protocol: Editors must recuse themselves from managing or making final decisions on manuscripts where they possess a conflict of interest stemming from competitive, collaborative, or other connections with any of the authors or associated organizations.

  • Delegation of Authority: In such instances, the evaluation and decision-making process will be delegated to an independent member of the Editorial Board or a designated guest editor.

  • Editorial Submissions: If an editor or Editorial Board member submits a manuscript to Acman: Accounting and Management Journal, the paper will undergo an independent double-blind peer-review process managed entirely by another member of the editorial team. The submitting editor will have no access to the review files or internal decision-making procedures.

4. Management of Undeclared Conflicts

If an undisclosed conflict of interest is discovered during the review process or after publication:

  1. The journal will initiate a formal inquiry in accordance with the flowcharts and recommendations established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

  2. The author(s) or party involved will be given an opportunity to provide written clarification.

  3. If an unstated conflict significantly undermines the manuscript's objectivity or scientific integrity, the Editor-in-Chief reserves the right to issue a formal Corrigendum, Expression of Concern, or Retraction Notice, depending on the severity of the omission.