R-W-C Policy

Retraction, Withdrawal, and Correction Policy

Acman: Accounting and Management Journal is dedicated to maintaining the integrity, accuracy, and completeness of the scholarly record. While both authors and editors strive for excellence throughout the peer-review and editorial processes, post-publication issues or pre-publication withdrawal requests may arise. The journal adheres strictly to the guidelines and flowcharts established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) in handling retractions, withdrawals, and corrections.

1. Article Retraction Policy

Retraction is reserved for published articles that contain severe errors or ethical breaches that undermine the reliability of the findings or conclusions.

Criteria for Retraction

A published article may be retracted if:

  • Unreliable Findings: There is clear evidence that the findings are unreliable due to major scientific flaws, whether resulting from misconduct (e.g., data fabrication or falsification) or honest errors (e.g., calculation errors or methodological flaws).

  • Redundant Publication: The work or substantial portions thereof have been published elsewhere without proper cross-referencing, permission, or disclosure.

  • Ethical Violations: The paper involves unethical behavior, such as severe plagiarism, self-plagiarism, unauthorized use of confidential data, or fraudulent/inappropriate authorship.

Retraction Procedure

  1. Reporting: Potential retraction cases brought to the attention of the Editor-in-Chief will be evaluated following standard COPE procedures.

  2. Investigation: The Editorial Board will review the concern and request formal responses or clarifications from the author(s).

  3. Decision & Notification: The final decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief. The outcome will be formally communicated to the authors and, when appropriate, their affiliated institutions or funding agencies.

  4. Publication of Notice: A formal Retraction Notice will be published in the online system and included in the next available issue. The original article will remain accessible in PDF format but will be clearly watermarked as "RETRACTED" to preserve the permanent public archive.

Note: Retention of copyright by the author(s) does not grant the right to unilaterally retract a published paper. The integrity of the scientific literature remains paramount.

2. Manuscript Withdrawal Policy

Unilateral manuscript withdrawal during peer review wastes significant editorial and reviewer resources and is considered poor academic etiquette.

  • Withdrawal Request Procedure: To request a manuscript withdrawal, the corresponding author must submit an official request signed by all co-authors to the Editor-in-Chief, clearly stating the reason.

  • Pre-Review / Submission Stage: If an author requests a withdrawal during initial screening without valid justification, the submission will be declined, and the authors may face temporary blacklisting.

  • Peer-Review / Post-Acceptance Stage: Authors are strictly discouraged from withdrawing manuscripts while under active peer review or after formal acceptance. If a manuscript is withdrawn at these stages without valid editorial grounds or failure to comply with journal policies, the authors and their academic affiliations may be suspended from submitting to Acman: Accounting and Management Journal for a period of up to three (3) years.

3. Article Correction Policy

Corrections are issued to rectify minor flaws or omissions that do not invalidate the overall scientific conclusions of the article.

A. Erratum

Published to notify readers of significant errors introduced by the journal during the layout or production process that adversely impact the article’s clarity or presentation.

B. Corrigendum

Published to inform readers of notable errors inadvertently made by the authors (e.g., minor data errors, omitted acknowledgments, or corrections to the author list). Authors must contact the Editor-in-Chief immediately upon discovering such errors.

C. Post-Acceptance Additions or Modifications

If authors wish to add or alter content after acceptance:

  • Additional Findings: Supplementary content that expands upon the accepted work must be submitted as a new manuscript referencing the original paper.

  • Content Replacement: If the new material replaces or modifies original accepted content, the Editor-in-Chief will determine whether an erratum or corrigendum is appropriate.

4. Article Removal (Extreme Cases)

In extraordinarily rare circumstances, an article may be completely removed from the journal's online database. This action is restricted to situations where:

  • The content is clearly defamatory or infringes upon legal rights/privacy.

  • The paper is subject to a formal court order.

  • The published findings pose a severe legal or health risk if acted upon.

In such instances, the article text will be removed and replaced with a notice indicating that the item has been removed for legal reasons. The bibliographic metadata (title, authors, and abstract) will remain retained to preserve indexing continuity.